Volume 13, Issue 1, 2020.

Ethical issues and challenges in psychological practice and research

• Decision Making and Ethical Reasoning in Psychology

  Ricou, M.; Marina, S.

  PDF HTML

  10406

  Volume 13, Issue 1, 2020.

  Ricou, M., Marina, S. (2020). Decision Making and Ethical Reasoning in Psychology. Psychology in Russia: State of the Art, 13(1), 2-10.

  “ CITE

  copied

  • Background. Rationality, emotions, and intuition all seem to underlie the decision-making process. In a profession such as psychology, it is crucial to improve the rational dimension of decision making. Ethical reasoning can be compared to moral decision-making, but it is also linked to professional judgment. In psychology and other professions, ethical reasoning seems to be the basis for the development of professional skills. 

    Objective. Present and discuss the role that rationality, emotions, and intuition can play in people's decision making, especially in the field of psychological intervention.

    Design. A theoretical perspective is presented which takes into account the relevant literature in the field.

    Results. We support the idea of five fundamental preconditions for ethical reasoning: self-knowledge, excellent training, experience or supervision, humility, and intervision. We recommend that psychologists meet these conditions in their professional decision making in order to promote the best quality of professional practice.

    Conclusion. We can say that ethical reasoning is a professional moral decision. As professionals, we are primarily intuitive in our decision making, which is why we make decisions almost automatically; but our decisions are based on our professional experience. Psychologists should reflect on and understand the processes involved in decision making in order to avoid conclusions based on their personal experiences. 

    Keywords: reason; emotions; intuitions; decision making; ethical reasoning; psychology

    DOI: 10.11621/pir.2020.0101

• The Ethical Problems in Forensic Psychological Expert Evaluation: A View from Modern Russia

  Shaboltas, A.V.; Khaleeva, M.; Gorbatov, S.V.; Arbuzova, E.N.

  PDF HTML

  8309

  Volume 13, Issue 1, 2020.

  Shaboltas, A.V., Gorbatov, S.V., Arbuzova, E.N., Khaleeva, M.V. (2020). The Ethical Problems in Forensic Psychological Expert Evaluation: A View from Modern Russia. Psychology in Russia: State of the Art, 13(1), 11-21.

  “ CITE

  copied

  • Background. The implementation of ethical principles in forensic psychology in Russia is facing serious challenges.  Expert’s evaluations have to be managed in accordance with the basic ethical principles of practical psychology in general. At the same time, the specific activities and role of a forensic psychologist differ from the professional activities and roles of a psychiatrist, psychologist-consultant, or psychotherapist. 

    Objective. This study focused on the identification of the main ethical problems of psychologists, who are obligated to conduct expert evaluations for the court. 

    Design. This study was conducted according to a qualitative paradigm, using a combination of the  methods: content analysis of court materials and written expert opinion; analysis of court cases; interviews with experts; and analysis of international standards and guidelines for the professional activities of forensic experts. 

    Results. The ethical problems are determined by several factors: 1) the lack of a scientific basis for the regulations; 2) the complexity of the role structure of the expert’s practice; 3) the lack of practically oriented studies devoted to ethics; and 4) the lack of a venue for systematic discussion and supervision. Ethical problems are often solved by specialist exclusively according to their personal attitudes which could be risky in terms of violations of professional ethics. 

    Conclusion. There is a lack of systematic studies on the ethical problems in forensic practice. The preliminary data show that the rapidly growing field of expert evaluation requires the closest attention in developing ethical standards and  understanding of the expert’s activity and role structure. 

    Keywords: ethical problems; forensic psychological evaluation; expert opinion; professional competence

    DOI: 10.11621/pir.2020.0102

• Ethical and Moral Levels in the Functioning of the Personality of the Educational Psychologist

  Veselova, E.K.; Korzhova, E.Yu.

  PDF HTML

  4564

  Volume 13, Issue 1, 2020.

  Veselova, E.K., Korjova, E.Yu. (2020). Ethical and Moral Levels in the Functioning of the Personality of the Educational Psychologist. Psychology in Russia: State of the Art, 13(1), 22-32.

  “ CITE

  copied

  • Background. There is a growing movement worldwide for ethical regulation of psychologists’ research-oriented, educational, and practical activities. However, expectations that the better the code of ethics, the safer and more effective the professional activity will be, are not being met. For this reason, it is beneficial to distinguish two levels of the psychologist’s professional functioning: that related to his or her role, and that on the personal level; this makes it possible to more adequately analyze the psychological aspects of ethical and moral regulation in professional interaction.

    Objective. To compare the psychological foundations of the educational psychologist’s ethical and moral professional behavior at the role and personal levels.

    Design. Analysis, generalization, and identification, through a review of the literature, of the main factors influencing the ethical and moral regulation of professional behavior of psychologists.

    Results. Surveys of specialists show that it is difficult both for the client and for the psychologist to follow a formal ethical code unconditionally. We considered the limitations of ethical regulation of professional activity, when, even with a good knowledge of the ethical norms on the part of the specialists, external monitoring is required to guarantee the safety of their subjects. We emphasize that the wide variety of psychological assistance provided by psychologists to their clients requires different degrees of personal involvement on the part of the specialist. We propose to distinguish two levels of professional interaction in the psychologist’s activity: the role level and the personal level, corresponding to different mechanisms of the moral regulation of the specialist’s behavior. At the role level, there is no need for deep personal involvement; the external motives of moral regulation (knowledge of the code requirements and fear of administrative sanctions for negative consequences) serve as psychological mechanisms of compliance with ethical standards. On the personal level, other psychological mechanisms are required for the performance of professional duties, such as internal motives underlying moral behavior (a mature and sensitive conscience and a positive philosophy of life). The personal level of moral professional behavior regulation makes it possible to provide a much greater degree of safety in the interaction between psychologist and client, and in the absence of external oversight.

    Conclusion. We compare two approaches to the explanation of the psychological foundations of moral functioning: models enumerating the personal qualities defining moral behavior and models of integrated moral functioning. The article describes the existential-ontological concept of moral functioning, correlating the maturity of individual moral consciousness, awareness of the adoption of a particular ethical system of norms and ideals, and the conscience. We conclude that it is necessary to educate future specialists as mature, integrated personalities, ensuring integrated moral functioning in their professional interactions.

    Keywords: ethical regulation of psychologists’ activity; moral functioning; authenticity; identity; conscience; existential concept of moral functioning; situations of moral choice

    DOI: 10.11621/pir.2020.0103

• Teaching and Learning Psychology Ethics as a Meaningful and Enjoyable Experience

  Korkut, Y.

  PDF HTML

  10311

  Volume 13, Issue 1, 2020.

  Korkut, Y. (2020). Teaching and Learning Psychology Ethics as a Meaningful and Enjoyable Experience. Psychology in Russia: State of the Art, 13(1), 33-41.

  “ CITE

  copied

  • Background. It is crucial for psychology students and graduates to study ethics. However, neither teaching nor learning ethics is always an easy process. Course syllabi often include philosophical texts, specialized concepts, and numerous ethics or procedural codes. Could we consider all of this as a cognitive process? The students should be aware of all the vulnerabilities that can impact ethical decision-making, such as cognitive errors, emotional factors, social and organizational pressures, and situational factors.

    There is a great deal of new research on the advantages of including emotional dimensions in the decision-making process (Decety & Cacioppo, 2012; Decety & Cowell, 2015); this research evenclaims that emotions strengthen the contribution of the cognitive process, and as a result enrich the final ethical judgments. Additionally, there is also a kind of hidden curriculum that we provide to students (Goold & Stern, 2006; Hafferty & Franks, 1994). It is exactly this area (internships, the way we relate to the students) to which we need to pay attention during their undergraduate and graduate years.

    Conclusion. Expecting students to learn and internalize knowledge in a meaningful way necessitates new modes of instruction. Specifically, teaching and learning ethics in an interactive way, while paying attention to both good decision-making skills and emotional cues, would provide exactly what students would enjoy and learn from the most. In this article, we will suggest that, if the question is how to sensitize students to ethical issues in psychology, and in the profession, it is important to give them an active role and responsibility for disseminating ethical principles. We will also introduce different techniques that help combine knowledge with emotionality while teaching ethics in psychology. 

    Keywords: psychology ethics; ethics in psychological practice; teaching ethics; teaching techniques; new methods; ethics course.

    DOI: 10.11621/pir.2020.0104

• Ethics of Clinical Supervision: An International Lens

  Falender, C.A.

  PDF HTML

  11569

  Volume 13, Issue 1, 2020.

  Falender, C. (2020). Ethics of Clinical Supervision: An International Lens. Psychology in Russia: State of the Art, 13(1), 42-53.

  “ CITE

  copied

  • Background. Although widely acknowledged as a distinct professional practice, clinical supervision has not consistently been a component of graduate training in psychology,and has not achieved recognition commensurate with its importance to the field in the United States or internationally. Although competence in supervision had been inferred, multiple international studies reveal high frequenciesof unethical, inadequate, and harmful supervision. Implicit in clinical supervision is ethical acumen, practice, modeling, teaching, andadherence to multiple ethical principles and codes.Specifically, this role calls for respect, integrity, doing no harm, competence, confidentiality, and not entering multiple relationships that may do harm.

    Objective. The objective of the current article is to describe the essential components of ethical clinical supervision and training, ethical imperatives for both supervisor and supervisee, and aspects of training and supervision that ensure protection of the client. A framework of enlightened globalization harmonizes rules and ideals of the profession with cultural diversity and provides both a structure and guidance for supervisors and supervisees.

    Results. We analyze the ethical development of supervisees which occurs through a complex process of integration of personal values and ethical positions with professional ethics; through an intentional, systematic process; and through supervision, to enhance their metacompetence (i.e.,knowing what one knows and doesn’t know). 

    Conclusion. Through a review of the strategic literature, we define current international and cultural perspectives on ethical practice and training, outline critical ethical issues, and provide strategies for effective and ethical clinical supervision, including an informed consent document and a supervision contract.
    

    Keywords: clinical supervision; ethics; ethical clinical supervision; supervision; international supervision.

    DOI: 10.11621/pir.2020.0105

• An Ethics of Inclusion: Recommendations for LGBTQI Research, Practice, and Training

  McGinley, M.; Horne, Sharon G.

  PDF HTML

  8874

  Volume 13, Issue 1, 2020.

  McGinley, M., Horne, S.G. (2020). An Ethics of Inclusion: Recommendations for LGBTQI Research, Practice, and Training. Psychology in Russia: State of the Art, 13(1), 54-69.

  “ CITE

  copied

  • Background. Throughout the last forty years, an emerging set of global norms addressing the rights and treatment of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, and intersex (LGBTQI) people have emerged and are continuing to evolve. This article will outline the trajectory of LGBTI concerns in the context of international human rights, and make a case for psychological ethics that are inclusive of concerns specific to sexual orientation, gender identity, and gender expression (SOGIE). These discussions will be framed in the context of the historical stigma and pathologization associated with SOGIE concerns, as well as the increasing global visibility and political and social organizing of LGBTQI communities.

    Discussion. First, the rise of international and regional ethics codes pertaining to SOGIE concerns, including the role of the United Nations, will be reviewed. Second, recommendations for an ethical approach to psychological research, practice, training, and advocacy inclusive of SOGIEconcerns will be discussed. These recommendations will be informed by the existing ethical framework of the European Federation of Psychologists’ Associations (EFPA), and will address the unique concerns of sexual orientation minority populations; transgender, non-binary, and gender-expansive (TNG) people; and intersex populations. Finally, the International Psychology Network for LGBTI Issues (IPsyNet) will be introduced as a model for networking in support of SOGIE interests within LGBTQI-affirming national psychological organizations.

    Conclusion. As European ethical practices respond to calls from human rights stakeholders for increased inclusion of SOGIE concerns, this paper proposes that it is the responsibility of international psychological practice to support the human rights of allglobal citizens.

    Keywords: Ethics; sexual orientation; gender identity; LGBTQI; human rights; sexual minority; gender minority; SOGIE; TNG

    DOI: 10.11621/pir.2020.0106

• A Little Lie Never Hurt Anyone: Attitudes toward Various Types of Lies over the Lifespan

  Buta, M.; Visu-Petra, G.; Koller, Silvia H.; Visu-Petra, Laura

  PDF HTML

  7147

  Volume 13, Issue 1, 2020.

  Buta, M., Visu-Petra, G., Koller, S.H., Visu-Petra, L. (2020). A Little Lie Never Hurt Anyone: Attitudes toward Various Types of Lies over the Lifespan. Psychology in Russia: State of the Art, 13(1), 70-81.

  “ CITE

  copied

  • Background. A growing body of evidence shows that people's attitudes toward lies could be predictive of their actual deceptive behavior. However, few studies have examined both attitudes and deceptive behavior, and none have related attitudes toward the likelihood of self-reported deception as it develops over people’s lifespans.

    Objective. Our study addresses attitudes toward lies and the likelihood of deceptive behavior in a variety of contexts, relating them to self-reported frequency of lying. We were also interested in whether individual differences in social desirability and social anxiety predict self-reported frequency of lying across lifespans.

    Design. Using a cross-sectional design that included children as well as young adults, we assessed a total of 177 participants with the same questionnaire about deception, adapted from Lundquist et al. (2009).

    Results. The age differences in the frequency of self-reported lying followed an inverted U-shape trend over time. Children’s lower social desirability and more lenient attitudes toward white lies predicted higher lying frequency, whereas for adults, a greater likelihood of telling prosocial lies predicted higher lying frequency.Children with decreased anxiety were less likely to tell prosocial lies, implying that anxiety might be a key factor in children’s development of deception.

    Conclusion. Our work offers an integrative view into people’s attitude towards deception and their self-reported lying as they mature. Attitudes toward white lies and the self-reported likelihood of telling prosocial lies were the most relevant predictors involved in self-reported lie-telling. Individual differences in anxiety and social desirability also played a relevant role in children’s and young adults’ attitudes toward deception.

    Keywords: attitudes; deception; lying frequency; anxiety; social desirability; prosocial lies; white lies

    DOI: 10.11621/pir.2020.0107

• Ethical Issues of Psychological Expert Testimony in Child Custody Cases: A Comparison of Ethical Approaches

  Baštecká, B.; Boukalová, H.

  PDF HTML

  8217

  Volume 13, Issue 1, 2020.

  Baštecká, B., Boukalová, H. (2020). Ethical Issues of Psychological Expert Testimony in Child Custody Cases: A Comparison of Ethical Approaches. Psychology in Russia: State of the Art, 13(1), 82-98.

  “ CITE

  copied

  • Background. Both authors are working on the Board of Ethics of the Czech-Moravian Psychological Society. They face a recurring pattern of complaints, where one parent in the multilateral contractual field of the child custody domain complains about the psychological report in their case, including the psychologist´s procedure, conduct, partiality, etc. The child custody domain is under Civil Law jurisdiction, where psychologists serving as expert witnesses report their evaluations at the request of the court.   

    Objective. To point out some of societal and professional challenges confronting psychologists as expert witnesses in child custody cases. To improve ethical awareness in this area of psychological expert witness practice. 

    Design. We compiled an overview of the complaints obtained by the Board of Ethics of the Czech-Moravian Psychological Society from 2013 to 2019, against psychologists who served as expert witnesses in child custody cases in the Czech Republic. We then compared these complaints with the ethical norms established by the Czech Code of Ethics of the Psychological Profession; the recommendations of the European Federation of Psychologists’ Associations (EFPA) (c.f., The European psychologist in forensic work and as expert witness); and the guidelines of the American Psychological Association (APA) (c.f., Guidelines for Child Custody Evaluations in Family Law Proceedings).  

    Results and Сonclusions. Testimony by psychological experts in child custody cases is occurring in the context of societal changes and political decisions concerning child custody arrangements, and the best interests of the child in the context of gender neutral laws. Several ethical concerns seem to be of special importance: 1) the “psychological best interest of the child” in the multilateral contractual field; 2) the purpose and contribution of psychological expert testimony in child custody cases; 3) the role, task, and responsibility of the expert witness, including establishing working alliances and parallel processes; 4) the appropriate allocation of responsibilities in the multilateral contractual field; and 5) the ethics of reflexivity, responsibility, and courage. The “complaint bias” is discussed.
    

    Keywords: psychologist as an expert witness; child custody cases; psychological best interest of the child; ethics of virtues; psychological and personal ethics of reflexivity, responsibility and courage

    DOI: 10.11621/pir.2020.0108

• Representations of Medical Risks and Their Connection to Different Personal Characteristics of Doctors and Medical Students

  Kornilova, T.V.; Pavlova, E.M.; Bogacheva, N.V.; Kamenev, I.I.; Krasavtseva, Yu.V.

  PDF HTML

  3539

  Volume 13, Issue 1, 2020.

  Kornilova, T.V., Pavlova, E.M., Bogacheva, N.V., Kamenev, I.I., Krasavtseva, Yu.V. (2020). Representations of Medical Risks and Their Connection to Different Personal Characteristics of Doctors and Medical Students. Psychology in Russia: State of the Art, 13(1), 99-120.

  “ CITE

  copied

  • Background. There is no generally accepted psychological understanding of how a doctor’s representation of risk and uncertainty affects professional medical decision-making. The concept of a Unified Intellectual and Personal Potential can serve as a framework to explain its multiple and multilevel regulation. Our objective was to research the connections between medics’ perceptions of risk and related personal factors.

    Design. Medical doctors were compared to different control groups to identify their personal and motivational characteristics in three studies. 

    Study 1 assessed the motivational profile of doctors (using Edwards Personal Preference Schedule) in connection with their risk-readiness and rationality (measured by the Personal Factors of Decision-making questionnaire, also known as LFR) in a sample of 33 doctors, as compared to 35 paramedics and 33 detectives. 

    Study 2 compared 125 medical students and 182 non-medical students to 65 doctors as to the levels of their risk perception (measured by Implicit Theories of Risk questionnaire, the LFR, and their direct self-esteem of riskiness [1]), tolerance for uncertainty (measured by Budner's questionnaire), and rating on the Big-Five personality traits (TIPI). 

    Study 3 presented two new methods of risk perception assessment and investigated the connection between personality traits, risk reduction strategies, and cognitive representations of risk in 66 doctors, as compared to 44 realtors.

    Results. Study 1 found differences between the doctors’, paramedics’, and investigators’ motivational profiles. The doctors’ motivations were not associated with conscious self-regulation. In Study 2, risk-readiness was positively related to tolerance for uncertainty (TU) and the self-esteem of riskiness. The latter was significantly lower in doctors compared to the student groups and had different relationships with personality variables. In Study 3, doctors differed from realtors not only in their traits (i.e.,being less willing to take risks), but also in their choices and greater integration of their risk representations.

    Conclusions. The three studies demonstrated the multilevel processes behind the willingness to take risks and risk acceptance, as well as the relationship between the multilevel personality traits and doctors’ assessments of medical risks and their preferences in risky decision-making.

    ---

    1. The “self-esteem of riskiness” refers to an individual’s self-esteem in light of their willingness to take risks. This formulation will be used throughout this article, as to constantly elaborate its meaning would be too unwieldy.

    Keywords: decision-making (DM); risk representation; risk-readiness; implicit theories (IT); Implicit Theories of Risk (ITR); self-esteem of riskiness; tolerance for uncertainty (TU); Big Five

    DOI: 10.11621/pir.2020.0109

Clinical psychology

• Psychological Rehabilitation of Patients with Cardiovascular Diseases by Correction of Cognitive Impairment

  Yanitskiy, M.S.; Seryy, A.V.; Vasyagina, N.N.; Solodukhin, A.V.; Trubnikova, O. A.

  PDF HTML

  4205

  Volume 13, Issue 1, 2020.

  Yanitskiy, M.S., Seryy, A.V., Vasyagina, N.N., Solodukhin, A.V., Trubnikova, O.A. (2020). Psychological Rehabilitation of Patients with Cardiovascular Diseases by Correction of Cognitive Impairment. Psychology in Russia: State of the Art, 13(1), 121-132.

  “ CITE

  copied

  • Background. This survey article reviews research and academic writings analyzing cognitive features of patients with cardiovascular diseases.

    Objective. To review the academic literature on the feasibility of psychological rehabilitation of cardiovascular patients by correcting cognitive impairment.

    Method. Analysis and compilation of academic writings by Russian and foreign researchers.

    Results. The cognitive dimension of coronary heart disease (CHD) patients has a number of features linked to the effect of their disease, and to their cognitive and psychological status. The article presents diagnostic techniques used to assess the patient’s cognitive state. The experimental data demonstrates the effectiveness of cognitive training with cardiovascular patients. The article also describes recommendations for cognitive rehabilitation of coronary heart disease patients, for choosing the right “target” of remedial psychological intervention, and for assessment of the recovery process.

    Conclusion. Rehabilitation programs are promising for patients with coronary heart disease and other somatic diseases.

    Keywords: psychological rehabilitation, cognition, remedial psychological training, cardiovascular disease, psychological-pedagogical process, neuropsychology

    DOI: 10.11621/pir.2020.0110

• Pièce Touchée!: Relationship Between Chess-Playing Experience and Inhibition

  Gindi, Sh.; Pilpel, A.

  PDF HTML

  5104

  Volume 13, Issue 1, 2020.

  Gindi, S., Pilpel, A. (2020). Pièce Touchée!: The Relationship Between Chess-Playing Experience and Inhibition. Psychology in Russia: State of the Art, 13(1), 133-146.

  “ CITE

  copied

  • Background. Studies have shown that teaching children and youths chess can contribute to their academic achievements and improve their cognitive abilities. Recent studies further indicate the transfer of chess skills to subjects such as mathematics. However, the literature does not address the possible benefits of chess to link between inhibition and ADHD, a disorder in the operational executive functioning system, whenwith chess ias a game that requires various cognitive abilities, and is considered dependent on executive operational functioning abilities and especially inhibition. 

    Objective. To investigate whether chess experience relates to inhibitory control in teenagers with and without ADHD. 

    Design. Participants completed a visual-spatial task designed for the pur- pose of the study, comprising two conditions: In the “free” condition, par- ticipants were allowed to test different solutions before choosing the answer, whereas in the “touch-move” condition they were asked to choose the answer without any physical attempts. Participants also completed “Go/No-go” tasks. 

    Results. The new task was found to be partially effective as only the “touch- move” condition produced group differences, with chess players performing better than non-chess players, regardless of diagnosis. The No-go task perfor- mance analysis also showed a significant main effect for chess training, and a significant interaction among chess, ADHD, and medicine use. 

    Conclusion. Although not establishing causality, these results indicate that chess players were less impulsive than non-chess players, regardless of diagnosis. 
    

    Keywords: ADHD; inhibitory control; executive function; impulsivity; education; chess

    DOI: 10.11621/pir.2020.0111

• The Impact of Family on Children’s Attitude Toward Health

  Pervichko, E.I.; Shishkova, I.M.

  PDF HTML

  9295

  Volume 13, Issue 1, 2020.

  Shishkova, I.M., Pervichko, E.I. (2020). The Impact of Family on Children’s Attitude toward Health. Psychology in Russia: State of the Art, 13(1), 147-160.

  “ CITE

  copied

  • Background. Parents have a significant impact on the formation of their children’s attitude toward health. A detailed study of this effect will allow us to devise strategies for interaction with children and directions of psychological correction of maladaptive behaviors in health issues.

    Objective. To study the relationship between attitude toward healthin primary-school-age children and their parents and styles of childrearing.

    Design. The study comprised 69 primary-school-aged children and their parents. The method of “Unfinished Sentences About Health” and the questionnaire “Analysis of Family Relationships” were used.Components of attitude toward healthsuch as health self-esteem, assessment of healthy people, diseases, health promotion actions, health promotion factors (causes), and the value of health were considered. 

    Results. [1]The findings showed that the parents’ components of attitude toward healthare interrelated with those in children’s at all levels (from behavioral to semantic and axiological) and are connected with the style of childrearing.

    Conclusion. Data analysis showed the impact of the style of childrearing and the interrelation of certain parental attitude toward healthcomponents with attitude toward health in primary-school-age children. This problem requires detailed study due to its theoretical significance and the obvious social challenges it presents.

    ---

    1. These are not Results, but part of the Design.

    
    
    
    

    Keywords: health psychology; attitude toward health; children’s health; family relationships; childrearing

    DOI: 10.11621/pir.2020.0112